34 ECONOMIC ESSAYS IN HONOR OF JOHN BATES CLARK
In order to deal effectively with any static state or any
economic equilibrium, it is necessary to know the factors and
forces that are in the balance. To be somewhat more specific
if it is desired to change an equilibrium wage to the advantage
of laborers, in a given occupation, it is necessary to know what
factors are at work inducing laborers to offer themselves for hire
in that occupation, or what factors are at work inducing
employers to offer to hire laborers. When this is once under-
stood in some detail, we may find some way of reducing the num-
ber who will offer themselves for hire at the old wage, or increas-
ing the number which employers would be willing to hire.
Either way would change the equilibrium, and require a higher
wage to bring about a balance between the number wanting
employment and the number wanted by employers.
If, for example, it is found that one factor in the equilibrium
of the demand for and supply of labor of a given kind is free
immigration from a low wage country, such as Mexico, China, or
India, so that a very low wage is sufficient to induce as many
laborers to offer themselves in this country as employers are able
or willing to hire, the effective method of meeting that situation is
to shut off these supplies of cheap labor. When this is done a
new equilibrium wage will establish itself without further effort.
In other words, it will then require a higher wage than formerly
to induce as many laborers to offer themselves as employers are
willing to hire.
If, on the other hand, instead of restricting immigration from
the overpopulated countries, wages are raised directly by decree,
it merely makes the country still more desirable to immigrants,
increases immigration, and, unless other and more drastic
measures are taken, the resulting industrial reserve army will
bring its long train of evils.
The employing classes, being presumably more familiar with
the laws of the market than are manual laborers, have generally
been able to out maneuver the laboring classes and to manipulate
these factors in the equilibrium wage to their own advantage.
They seem, at least, to have a fairly clear understanding of the
procedure. An illustration of this is found in a statement of the
late Frank A. Munsey before the American Bankers’ Association
in 1922. He, like many of his class, seemed to know exactly what
he wanted and how to get it.