INTRODUCTION

tory ’, because the property has passed under them.
But the term is misleading to us because of the sense
in which it is ordinarily used in the English language,
nor is the alternative ‘ dispositive * suggested by later
English writers much more lucid. It serves little useful
purpose, however, to dwell on a question of pure
terminology ; the English lawyer will understand what
is meant if these treaties be called ‘ executed ’. The
real reason of the exception of this class of treaties is
that title rests on a completed act, and not on a treaty
obligation of which the liability is still continuing.
It has been said that within the class of treaties
which remain unaffected by war are included treaties
which create rights over land, and are sometimes called
international servitudes. But in the absence of express
stipulation the usage of nations affords no sufficient
foundation for the recognition of a special class of
treaty rights vested with special attributes, and in particular
 with the attribute of permanency in spite of war,
such as is assumed in the conception of international
servitudes. The distinction is largely the creation of
text-writers, working on the analogy of the rights known
as servitudes in Roman law ; a dangerous analogy since
the rules of private property cannot be applied with
any degree of exactness to the sovereign rights of
States. There seems no reason why rights conferred:
by treaty on one State to be exercised in the territory
of another State should be in any different position
from that of other treaty rights; and, indeed, that
this is so would appear from the personal element
which is inherent in most such grants to a greater or
less extent. State A before war may be willing to
admit the subjects of State B to the enjoyment of
certain rights in the A territories; but after war,