INTRODUCTION

vii

relations stand on an altogether different footing.
The fact is, that the personal element enters largely
into treaty concessions and that they bear no real
analogy to private rights of servitude. Moreover,
if that analogy were to apply at all, it must apply
equally to the common case of treaties conferring rights
of entering and residing for the purposes of trade,
for those are rights to be exercised on the soil, if the
connexion with the soil is to be the test. But any
extension such as that would be opposed to wellestablished
 usage. The general question of servitudes
was threshed out in the North Atlantic Fisheries
Arbitration at The Hague in 1910, and the Award of
the Tribunal is an express decision that treaty rights
of fishing in territorial waters stand in no different
Position from any other treaty rights and that there
is no special law of servitudes applicable to such a case,
even if there be any such special class of servitude
rights at all. The decision on this point has not been
accepted in its entirety by all text-writers; some of
them already committed to the theory of servitudes are
reluctant to acquiesce in an adverse judgement. But
it is thought that the Award is a correct statement of
international law and that it is in accordance with the
Practice of nations; for though there is authority for
the general doctrine of servitudes to be found in the
Opinion of jurists (and even they are not in agreement
as to the extent and the attributes of a servitude), there
is little or no precedent in the usage of nations.!
Indeed, the investigation of the matter at The Hague
demonstrated. as is submitted. that the doctrine could

‘ For instance, the French treaty-right of fishing on the Newfoundland
 coast (Treaty of Utrecht, 1713) was renewed in express
terms after every war between France and Great Britain.