TERMINABLE TREATIES Ii

them, war being considered, with certain exceptions, as
having the effect of abrogating treaties, or by the advent
of special circumstances incompatible with its continued
observance. These are matters which need not here be
entered into : it will be sufficient to note one well-known
instance in which an abrogation without consent has been
attempted, namely, in the case of the Black Sea Articles
of the Treaty of Paris of 1856, regarding which the Russian
Government announced, in 1870, that it held itself to be
emancipated. Great Britain replied that. it had always
been held that the right of releasing a party to a treaty
belonged only to the Governments which had been parties
to the original instrument. Russia’s bare announcement
of withdrawal, if acquiesced in, would result in the entire
destruction of treaties in their essence. Russia thereupon
abandoned the position she had taken up, and a conference
was held in London at which the articles objected to were
amended by common consent, and a Declaration was at
the same time signed by the Powers (including Russia) on
January 17, 1871, recognizing ‘that it is an essential
Principle of the Law of Nations that no Power can liberate
itself from the engagements of a Treaty, nor modify the
stipulations thereof, unless with the consent of the Contracting
 Powers by means of an amicable arrangement’.
The Treaty for the revision of the Black Sea Articles of
the Treaty of 1856 was signed on March 13, 1871.2 Russia,
therefore, gained her ends, or some of them, while the
essential principle of the Law of Nations ’ was vindicated
by the assent of the Powers. The annexation of Bosnia
and Herzegovina by Austria, on October 8, 1908, was in
effect a repudiation of Article XXV of the Treaty of Berlin,
July 13, 1878, although in her circular to the Powers
announcing the annexation, the Austrian Government
simply ignored the existence of the Treaty.

i
2

State Papers, vol. Ixi, p. 1198,
Ibid., vol. Ixi, p. 7.