TREATY OF 1839 125

the Scheldt, along with the Rhine, Neckar, Main, Moselle,
and Meuse, to be open to navigation, but the territorial
position of the Dutch on the estuary remained unchanged.
At the opening of the European War in August 1914 the
Dutch Government declared the estuary of the Scheldt to
be territorial waters of the Kingdom of the Netherlands, and
consequently that they would not permit ‘the passage
across the territory situated within the territorial waters of
the Netherlands by the warships or ships assimilated theretd
of the belligerents’* During the siege of Antwerp in
October 1914 no attempt was made by the Allies to use
the estuary of the Scheldt for warlike purposes, but the
position of these waters in international law has never yet
been precisely acknowledged or defined.
The provisions of the Treaty of 1831 were incorporated
in the Treaty of 1839, which has since then regulated the
position of Belgium in international law. The treaty was
made between Great Britain, Austria, France, Prussia, and
Russia, on the one hand, and the Netherlands on the other.
By Article II the treaty and its annex were placed ‘ under
the guarantee ’ of the five Powers. Holland was not one
of the guarantors. By this Article, each Power undertook
to guarantee the position of Belgium as defined by the
whole treaty. This was not a mere collective undertaking,
where the guaranteeing Powers bind themselves to act
together as one body. It was an individual obligation
imposed by each Power on itself? The guarantee with
respect to Luxemburg, made in 1867, was collective? - An
individual guarantee is, if anything, more emphatic than
a collective one, but the moral obligation imposed by one
or the other is just the same. Belgium was thus put into
what was considered, by the Powers, to be the very eligible
position of a State, with its integritv and neutrality guaran-2


3

Belgian Grey Book, in Collected Diplomatic Documents, p. 327
See the remarks of Lord Clarendon, Hansard, June 20, 1867.
See p. 258.