160 TURKEY AND THE POWERS, 1856
Disputes over these points led to the outbreak of the
Crimean War.
The question of the Latin Church came forward in 1851,
and caused acute feeling. The church at Bethlehem, built
over the place where Christ was born, was in charge of monks
of the Orthodox or Greek Church. The Latin monks of
Bethlehem did not claim the church itself, but they claimed
the right of having the key of the chief door, and also of
placing a silver star with the arms of France within the
sanctuary of the Nativity. By the end of the year 1852,
Napoleon III, who had in the previous year succeeded in
making himself Emperor of the French, gained from the
Turkish Government recognition of the claims of the Latin
monks. The dispute about the Holy Places was thus
settled with a victory for France.
The dispute about the Holy Places had no direct bearing
on the Crimean War, because it was settled before the war
was thought of. But the triumph of France in the dispute
hurt the pride of the Tsar Nicholas I, and injured the
religious feelings of the Russians, for whom pilgrimages to
Palestine were a real thing. Nicholas therefore put forward
the claims of Russia to protect all the subjects of the Porte
who were members of the Orthodox, that is, the Greek
Church. The Turkish Government denied that any such
right was conferred by the Treaty of Kutschuk-Kainardji.
The claim of the Russian Government was indeed rather
a serious one. The Orthodox subjects of the Porte numbered
 millions, and formed really a separate nation inside
Turkey. To acknowledge the Russian Government as the
protector of that nation would be tantamount to giving
away a portion of Turkish sovereignty. The mission of
Prince Menshikoff to Constantinople in 1853 had no effect
upon the Turks, who were kept firm in their attitude by
the great English ambassador, Lord Stratford de Redcliffe.
A conflict of wills was thus set up between the Russian
and Turkish Governments. As Nicholas could not by