258 THE GRAND DUCHY OF LUXEMBURG

greatest States of the Continent hung over Europe. The
British Government worked to avert this, and proposed the
meeting of a Conference, the wholesome means by which,
from 1815 till 1914, the calamities of war have been many
times averted. In the Conference, which took place at
London, Great Britain, Austria, Belgium, France, Italy,
the Netherlands, Prussia, and Russia, concluded the Treaty
of May 11, 1867, which defined anew the position of
Luxemburg in international law.
The treaty recognized Luxemburg as a perpetually
neutral State. The High Contracting Parties specially
put it upon record in Article II, that they ‘engage to
respect the principle of neutrality ’, and that they * placed
it under the sanction of the collective Guarantee of the
Powers signing Parties to the present Treaty, with the
exception of Belgium ’.
This guarantee differed from that given to Belgium in
two important respects. In the first place, it was a collective
 guarantee, whereas that given to Belgium has always
been held to be individual. When the Luxemburg Treaty
was concluded, the Earl of Derby, then Prime Minister,
explained that ‘a collective guarantee is one which is
binding on all the parties collectively ; but [of] which, if
any difference of opinion should arise, no one of them can
be called upon to take upon itself the task of vindication
by force of arms’? The guarantee might therefore prove
valueless, if one of the signing parties chose to disregard it.
The second difference was that although Luxemburg, like
Belgium, was bound by treaty to observe neutrality towards
all other States, yet she was not bound to defend that neutrality
 by force of arms. In effect she was forbidden actively
to defend her neutrality, by the terms of Article III, which
forbade her to maintain any fortified places or military
forces. The Prussian garrison, of course, had to evacuate

i Hansard, July 4, 1867.