268 THE FRANCO-GERMAN WAR
was argued, however, by France that this was not sufficient,
and that some guarantee should be given by Prussia that
Prince Leopold’s candidature would not be revived. Lord
Granville, thereupon, whilst regretting that France was
unable to accept the mere withdrawal as a sufficient concession,
 submitted a memorandum for communication to
the King of Prussia recommending that as the King had
consented to the acceptance by Prince Leopold of the
throne of Spain, and had thereby in a certain sense become
a party to the arrangement, His Majesty might with
perfect dignity communicate to the French Government
his consent to the withdrawal of that acceptance, in the
event of France waiving her demand for an engagement
covering the future. Count Bismarck replied by telegraph
(on the 14th or 15th July) that he regretted that Her
Majesty’s Government should have made a proposal
which it would be impossible for him to recommend to the
King for his acceptance, and he went on to allude to the
question of the succession, as he had previously done, as
a private matter in which Prussia was not concerned.
A letter of July 10, 1870, from King William of Prussia to
King Charles of Roumania shows that the Prussian Government
 knew and approved of the Hohenzollern candidature
for the Spanish throne,? and there is no doubt that Bismarck
made use of it for the furtherance of his political aims.
The history of the ‘ Ems telegram’ is instructive on this
point, as told by Bismarck and Busch.
It appears that von Roon, the Prussian War Minister,
and Moltke were dining with Bismarck on July 13 (1870).
In the course of the repast intelligence arrived from the
Prussian Embassy at Paris to the effect that the Prince of
Hohenzollern had renounced the Spanish throne in order
to prevent the war with which France threatened Prussia.
Bismarck says, ‘My first idea was to retire from the
! State Papers, vol. Ix, p. 826.
* See Aus dem Leben Konig Karls von Rumanien. (Stuttgart,
1894.) Band II, 101. Letter dated 28 June-10 July 1870.