GORCHAKOV

313

waters. It should be borne in mind also, that the upper
classes of Russia have for a long time been distinguished
for the keen and lively interest which they take in the
foreign affairs of their country. This is due to the fact
that the autocratic Constitution of Russia to a great
extent excluded the educated classes from participating
in the internal government of their country. Their attention
 was therefore largely concentrated upon foreign policy,
all the more since an active interest in this carried with it
no such personal risks as were involved in too obvious an
interest in the domestic affairs of government.
Alexander II had for his chief minister Prince Alexander
Gorchakov, descended from an ancient and distinguished
family. Gorchakov’s knowledge of foreign affairs was
unrivalled, and his prestige in the Chancelleries of Europe
stood very high. In 1870-1 he was able to carry out the
denunciation of the clauses of the Paris Treaty of 1856,
which neutralized the Black Sea.
The moment chosen for this dramatic announcement
was October 31, 1870, when France, who, with England,
was the great upholder of the Treaty of Paris, was involved
in the disastrous war with Germany, and had lost her great
field armies at Sedan and Metz. Gorchakov’s circular
to the Powers of Europe, announcing the repudiation of
the Black Sea Convention, was dated four days after the
capitulation of Metz.
The grounds upon which Gorchakov based his denunciation
 of Articles XI, XIII, and XIV of the Treaty of Paris,
and the Convention of the same date between Russia and
Turkey embodying those Articles, were two : first, that the
provisions of the Treaty of Paris had been broken in other
respects ; and second, that the neutralization of the Black
Sea was unreasonable. The first contention was unproved,
nor even, if true, would it necessarily have justified the
breaking of the rest of the treaty. The second contention
~that the Black Sea neutralization was unreasonable—