314 TURKEY, RUSSIA, AND BALKAN STATES
was a fair ground for discussion, and for modifying the
treaty by arrangement with the signatory and guaranteeing
Powers. But Gorchakov took no such course. His circular
of October 31, 1870, was simply a curt notice of denunciation.

The circular itself was not quite ingenuous. It contended
that the changes which had taken place in Roumania were
a breach of the Treaty of Paris. Article XXII of that
treaty stated that ‘the Principalities of Wallachia and
Moldavia shall continue to enjoy under the Suzerainty of
the Porte, and under the Guarantee of the Contracting
Powers, the Privileges and the Immunities of which they
are in possession’. These privileges had certainly been
increased since the Treaty of Paris, for the two Principalities
 had united themselves into one, and had in 1866
elected a foreign Prince in place of the native Prince
Alexander Couza. The Powers at first had objected to
the election of a Prince belonging to a foreign Royal
House, but they speedily acquiesced in the election of
Prince Charles Antony, of the House of Hohenzollern-Sigmaringen.
 This was no breach of the Treaty of Paris,
which had secured to the Principalities their existing
privileges, but could not be held perpetually to forbid the
acquisition of new privileges. In any case, even if modifica-~
tion had taken place in the Treaty of Paris, this could be
no ground for Russia arbitrarily modifying other clauses
of it, without consulting the Powers who were responsible
with her for the Treaty.
The other point in which Gorchakov said the Paris
Treaty had been broken was in the clause which declared
the Straits closed to foreign ships of war when the Porte
was at peace. ‘Repeatedly,’ ran the circular, ‘and
under various pretexts, Foreign Men-of-War have been
suffered to enter the Straits, and whole Squadrons, whose
presence was an infraction of the character of absolute
Neutrality attributed to those waters, admitted to the