318 TURKEY, RUSSIA, AND BALKAN STATES

put with all the logic and cogency which distinguished
Lord Granville’s dispatches. The Black Sea Convention
was denounced, yet at the same time Russia was induced
to submit the matter to discussion at a Congress of Powers
held at London in 1871. Although the mischief had been
already done, the Powers attempted some sort of vindication
 of the principle of treaty-obligation. They converted
Russia’s denunciation into a solemn treaty (March 13,
1871), and so put it upon a regular footing.
The Treaty annulled Articles XI, XIII, and XIV of the
Paris Treaty of 1856, and the separate and purely consequential
 Black Sea Convention of the same date ; Article XI
interdicted the Black Sea to the Flag of War of any nation ;
Article XIII prohibited the maintenance of military or
maritime arsenals on the coasts; Article XIV declared the
annexed Black Sea Convention to have the same force as
if embodied in the Treaty, and also that the Paris Treaty
could not be changed without the consent of the signatory
Powers. These Articles were replaced by a fresh one!
which retained the principle of the closure of the Straits
to foreign war-ships, but which differed from the provisions
of the 1856 Treaty in three important respects: (I) it
made no mention of the neutralization of the Black Sea,
where accordingly Russia could build navies and fortify
ports; (2) it permitted Turkey to open the Straits to foreign
ships of war, if the Porte should consider such a course
necessary in order to fulfil the stipulations of the Paris
Treaty of 1856, in so far as these stipulations were still in
force; (3) the statement that the Treaty could only be modified
 with the consent of the signatory Powers was omitted.
The reasons for these differences between the Treaties
of 1856 and 1871 were probably somewhat as follows :
1. That Russia should be able to fortify its own coast
on the Black Sea, and to maintain warships there, was
only reasonable ; otherwise, during a war with Turkey, the
1 Article II of the Treaty of March 13, 1871.