REASONS FOR THE CHANGES 319

Black Sea coast of Russia would be exposed without defence
to foreign ships of war, which the Porte could let through
the Dardanelles. It is true that the Treaty of Paris, by
interdicting the Black Sea to the ships of war of any
Power (Article XI), intended to protect Russia from such
a contingency. But a state of war between Russia and
a majority (including Turkey) of the signatory Powers
would bring the Treaty of Paris practically into abeyance,
and would expose Russia’s Black Sea coast to immediate
attack. Moreover, there was some inconsistency between
Article XI of the Treaty of Paris, which neutralized the
Black Sea, and Article I of the annexed Convention
(having the same force as the Treaty of Paris), which
allowed the Porte to admit foreign ships of war to the
Dardanelles and Bosphorus, when the Porte itself was at
war. It was of no use to neutralize the Black Sea in one
Article, and in another to authorize Turkey to pass ships
of war into it. The Treaty of 1871 was therefore consistent
and reasonable : it left Article I of the Black Sea Convention
 in force, i.e. the Straits were to remain closed
to foreign ships of war while the Porte was at peace;
and in order that the south coast of Russia and her commerce
 in the Black Sea might not be at the mercy of the
Turks during war, Russia was authorized to fortify herself
there, and maintain a navy. Turkey, of course, was given
the same authorization.
2. Turkey was not merely authorized to pass foreign
ships of war through the Straits in time of war, but also
(Article IT of the 1871 Treaty) in time of peace, ‘in case
the Sublime Porte should judge it necessary in order to
secure the execution of the stipulations of the Treaty of
Paris of the 30 March 1856°. It is very difficult to see
what stipulations are referred to, but the new rule was
probably made to prevent Russia from contending (as she
did in her circular of October 31, 1870) that the Treaty
of Paris had been broken, if Turkey, bona fide, admitted a