306. oi. THE CALCUTTA REVIEW

[nag

classes) are increasing, while interest enjoyed by- private capitalists
 is not increasing. “He argues in behalf of the necessity
of providing facilities for the promotion of “private capital.”
Progress depends on the taking of risks by private capital.
New technical advances are not as a rule appreciated by
governments. Every new Idea in government enterprise is
borrowed of private. Governments are competent only for routine
work. Guild socialism is condemned as utopian and impractical :
“ Mr. Cole seems to follow closely in the paths of St. Simon,
Fourier and other early socialists of noble character and vivid
poetic imagination. The task of regulation is to be as simple as
it-would be-if all men were as unselfish and earnest as the writer
himself, The vast difficulties of modern business organisation
are so completely left out of account as to imply that they have
never been seriously studied.”” (c) Marshall’s social philosophy
is: profoundly. nationalistic (patriotic) : Money, Credit. and
Commerce (1923) : Sentiments are not always firmly based on
reason; but economic reasonings which ignore them are likely to
mislead. Labour and capital tend to migrate less easily between
country and country than between different parts of the same
country. The problems of national defence and national finance
necessitate a firm control over a country’s frontiers and dictate
fiscal and financial policies.
1919. Land-reform in Germany: - The government. dictates
 limits to the amount of landed property to be held by
single individuals. This is but another instance of the class
of modern phenomena described in. Charmont’s Les Transformations
 du droit civil (Transformations of private or civil law.!)
1919. French Syndicalist Congress at Liyons :. “Nationalization
 of land and water-transport, mines, water power and

On land-reform in Germany, Denmark, Great Britain and the Egan
States, see Sarkar : Economic Development (Madras, 1926), ** Die Bodenfrage in Russland. |
Die Bodenfrage in England, and Die Bodenfrage tn Deutschland (Land questions 11
Russia, England and Germany) before and since the Great War in ‘Damaschke’s Bue
reform, Jena, 1923 ; Hainisch : Die Landflucht, Jena, 1924; von Schullern Aqrarpolitik.
Jena, 1923,