AIDS  TO  THE  LABOURER.

if'5
club.  But  what  becomes  of  the  old  men,  who  had
pinched  themselves  for  many  years  to  secure  a
provision  for  their  old  age  ?  This  selfish  and  dishonest ­
  practice  is  so  general  throughout  the  country
as  to  have  caused  the  Commissioners  to  report
most  unfavourably  of  the  operation  of  benefit
societies.
rhe  Commissioners  differ,  however,  a  good  deal
in  regard  to  the  details  of  these  institutions.  Some
think  that  the  annual  celebration,  with  its  procession, ­
  its  banners,  its  sermon,  and  its  dinner,  simply
entails  drunkenness  and  waste  of  funds,  and  that
it  ought  to  be  abolished.  Mr.  Stanhope  thinks,  on
the  contrary,  that  these  things  are  so  great  an
attraction,  and  form  so  strong  an  inducement  to
the  labourer  to  join  a  club,  that,  if  we  think  it  good
for  him  to  do  so,  we  ought  not  to  discourage  them.
We  must  say  we  think  it  doubtful  how  far  the
advocates  of  the  opposite  view  come  into  court
with  clean  hands.  The  intimate  connection  which
exists  in  England  between  charity  and  conviviality
is  so  old  a  joke  that  we  can  now  refer  to  it  without
joking  ;  and  if  rich  people,  whose  life  is  one  long
holiday,  or  men  of  business,  whose  evenings  are