172  THE  AGRICULTURAL  LABOURER.

sider  the  receipt  of  club  allowances  a  bar  to  parochial ­
  relief,  and  sometimes  they  don’t.  Uniformity
of  custom  should  surely  be  established  upon  this
point.  Mr.  Norman  wonders  that  the  poor  ever  do
practise  self-denial  for  the  sake  of  a  maintenance
in  old  age,  when  the  Poor  Law  will  give  it  them
without,  and  feels  sure  that  “  this  has  a  direct
“  tendency  to  weaken  those  feelings  of  self-reliance
“  and  independence  among  the  labouring  classes,
“  on  the  development  of  which  qualities  the  ame-“
  lioration  of  that  class  must  necessarily  depend.”
Mr.  Portman  (p.  165)  writes  to  the  same  effect.  But
the  problem  which  is  raised  by  all  three  seems
almost  insoluble,  except  by  abolishing  the  system
of  out-door  relief  altogether.  As  for  going  into  the
“  House,  the  poor  have  not  grown  indifferent  to
that  humiliation,  and  would  still  make  sacrifices  to
avert  it.  But  we  don’t  see  how  it  is  possible  to
disconnect  parish  relief  and  improvidence.  To  tell
a  man  to  starve  in  the  streets  because  he  has  not
had  sufficient  self-denial  to  provide  for  his  old  age
is  to  defeat  the  very  object  of  the  Poor  Law.  To
say  you  will  relieve  none  but  those  who  have  been
provident  is  simply  to  say  that  you  will  relieve