206  THE  AGRICULTURAL  LABOURER.

their  logical  extremes  would  be  a  relapse  into  chaos.
So  with  the  political  economist—he  properly  objects
to  being  required  to  bind  himself  by  certain  formulae ­
  ;  to  apply  doctrines  to  one  set  ot  circumstances ­
  which  are  applicable  only  to  another  ;  or  to
set  up  the  laws  of  his  own  science  as  paramount
to  all  other  considerations.  If  they  are  occasionally ­
  incompatible  with  the  highest  moral  results,
he  would  give  the  preference  to  these.  Even  if  small
farms  and  small  properties  do  produce  a  little  less
materially,  still  if  they  produced  a  great  deal  more
morally,  than  large  ones,  he  would  be  bound  to
prefer  the  former.  It  is  of  the  highest  importance
to  bear  this  argument  in  mind,  because  it  cuts  both
ways,  and  may  be  used  in  favour  of  our  own  system
as  well  as  in  favour  of  the  continental.
We  have  hitherto  quoted  the  opinions  of  the
Commissioners  solely  as  to  small  proprietors.
What  they  say  of  these  applies  à  fortiori  to  small
farmers.  And  we  find  throughout  the  Reports  a
singular  unanimity  on  this  head.  They  regret  the
disappearance  of  small  farms,  which  held  out  a
prospect  of  independence  to  the  labouring  class.
But  they  look  forward  hopefully  to  a  substitute  for