ELASTICITY OF SUPPLY AS A DETERMINANT OF DISTRIBUTION 113
important of these are: (1) the complications introduced by con-
sidering more than two factors of production, (2) the complica-
tions introduced by considering more than one commodity, (3)
the influence which is exercised by the relative amounts of labor,
capital and land rent embodied in the commodities and services
which are consumed by the recipients of interest, wages, and
rent, (4) the influence of the relative elasticity of demand for
these commodities and services. Each of these forces will now
be briefly considered and their influence evaluated.
1. The complications introduced by considering more than two
factors of production. We have hitherto been considering in a
very simplified manner only two factors which we have at times
labelled labor and capital. But there is, of course, land and
natural resources which is a third factor. Most modern theorists
following Francis A. Walker also set up a fourth factor, namely
management. It is difficult to recognize this, however, as a
distinct economic category or to regard its payment, profits, as
any unified return. The management of an enterprise would seem
to fall under the category of labor and the wages of management
to be indeed but a species of wages. The work of management
undoubtedly calls for talents of a high order. Such talents may
be so rare that there is competitive bidding for them, which makes
the returns received partake of the nature of rent, in the sense
that a surplus is paid over the cost of furnishing the service.
Management also bears the risk but this more and more can be
settled on actuarial basis. It is, moreover, doubtful whether
taking business as a whole, the payments for risk bearing are
greater than the losses incurred. There remain residual profits
and these have been more resorted to by economists as a catch-
all to accommodate returns which cannot be attributed to land,
capital, labor, than as a reward for a separate type of service.
They result from dynamic changes in production which are not
immediately distributed to the factors and from changes in
the demand schedules of commodities, which for a space give
creat rewards to some. They arise from the failure of the fac-
tors to move with the speed and intelligence which ordi-
narily ascribed to them by economists. Residual profits, there-
fore, accrue because of friction and time lags rather than as
* On this point, see Knight, Risk, Uncertainty and Profit; Hardy, Risk
and Risk-bearing.