14 TWO YEARS OF FAULTY TAXATION
The following table may therefore be of some
interest. It shows what percentage of returns
would have to be obtained from such sources in
order to equal the return from a 414%, tax-exempt
bond purchased at par. It shows, to take an extreme
instance, that in the case of a person in the
highest taxable class, he would have to make nearly
17% upon a corporate security or in his business
in order to get the same return which he receives
by investing in a tax-free 4149, bond.
And it should be remembered that in making
up these figures no account is taken of the excess
profit tax, which still further increases the yield
from tax-free securities as compared to the yield
from capital invested in business. Nor is account
taken of State income taxes or local taxation.
Here is the table:
A taxable security or a business would have to
yield the following percentages of return in order
to bring the same net income as a 4149, tax-free
bond (without calculating excess profits, State and
local taxes):
ascertained be considered as the rate applicable to the actually
taxable portion of his income.
Leaving aside the question of the legality and propriety of that
method, it manifestly would not accomplish that which ought to be
accomplished. There is only one way to reduce the advantage of
tax-exempt securities, and that is, in addition to adjusting our supertaxes
to reasonable proportions, to devise methods and ways of
taxation (such as the expenditures tax or the sales tax referred to
in the latter part of this discussion) which cannot be evaded by the
ownership of non-taxable securitics.