Full text : The history of trade unionism

Edition of 1911. © xvii

isting or possible associations of different kinds. It was
to include all sorts of Employers’ Associations as well as
Trade Unions, It was to include bodies already in existence
as well as those to be formed in the future. It was to include
 bodies seeking to impose restrictive conditions “in
restraint of trade,” as well as those having no such unlawful
objects. It was to include, therefore, bodies already enjoying
 a full measure of lawful existence and legal recognition,
as well as those for the first time fully legalized by the
legislation of 1871-6. To the logician it will be clear that
we have here a case of classification by type, not by delimitation.
 “It is determined,” says Whewell and J. S. Mill,
“not by a boundary line without, but by a central point
within; not by what it strictly excludes, but by what it
eminently includes; by an example, not by a precept”!
Accordingly the definition names specifically one by one
the various attributes, any one of which is to be typical of
the class. It does not occur to the ordinary reader, any
more than to the logician, that the effect of the clause
is to limit the legal freedom of all those associations, with
all their varied functions, exclusively to the purposes specified
 in the definition, which happen to be those alone in
which they resemble each other. On the construction put
upon this clause by the Six Judges, the Act of 1876 was
a measure which deprived Trade Unions and Employers’
Associations, many of which had been for years in existence
without any unlawful objects or methods, of a freedom
that they had up to then enjoyed ; it was an Act rigidly
confining their operations to a limited field, and for ever
prohibiting them (as Lord Halsbury expressly declares)
! Whewell, History of Scientific Ideas, vol. ii, p. 120; Mill, System of
Logic, vol. ii, p. 276.
            
Waiting...

Note to user

Dear user,

In response to current developments in the web technology used by the Goobi viewer, the software no longer supports your browser.

Please use one of the following browsers to display this page correctly.

Thank you.