XX
Introduction to the
Association ” classes ; the subscription for circulating bookboxes;
the provision of public lectures; the establishment
of scholarships at Ruskin College, Oxford, or any other
College—all of which things are now being done by Trade
Unions—are all plainly #/tra vires and illegal. The two
hundred Trades Councils, which are local federations of different
Trade Unions for the purpose of dealing with matters
of general interest to workmen, and which take no part in the
collective bargaining of any particular Trade Union, are
probably equally illegal; though they were in 1876 already
a quarter of a century old, and now number nearly a million
members. The annual Trade Union Congress itself, now in
its fortieth year, comes under the same ban. The active participation
which Trade Unions have here and there taken
in technical education, and their co-operation with the
Local Education Authorities, which has sometimes been
found so useful, is certainly ultra vires. One would suppose,
strictly speaking, that a similar illegality now attaches to
all the vast “friendly society ” side of Trade Unionism,
with its sick and accident and out of work benefits—not
one of them being referred to in the definition which the
Six Judges believe to contain an exhaustive enumeration
of the purposes and objects that Parliament intended to
permit Trade Unions to pursue. But here the Six Judges
save themselves by holding that these friendly benefits,
though not mentioned in the definition clause, are referred
to elsewhere in the Act, and may be regarded as incidental
to the purpose of regulating the conditions of employment.
This, indeed, so far as benefits paid to the workman himself
are concerned, is a plausible view. Strike Benefit, in
particular, is plainly incidental to striking, and sick benefit
may be held to protect the worker from industrial oppres-