The Funta.
221
It is difficult to-day to convey any adequate idea of the
extraordinary personal influence exercised by these five
Men, not only on their immediate associates, but also as
Interpreters of the Trade Union Movement, upon the
public and the governing classes. For the first time in
the century the working-class movement came under the
direction, not of middle and upper class sympathisers like
Place, Owen, Roberts, O'Connor, or Duncombe, but of
genuine workmen specially trained for the position. For
the first time, moreover, the leaders of working-class politics
Stood together in a compact group, united by a close
Personal friendship, and absolutely free from any trace
of that suspiciousness or disloyalty which have so often
Martred popular movements. ‘They brought to their task,
it is true, no consistent economic theory or political
Philosophy. They subscribed with equal satisfaction to
the crude Collectivism of the ¢ International,” and the
dogmatic industrial Individualism of the English Radicals.
This absence of a definite basis to their political activity
Accounts, we think, for the drying up of Trade Union
politics after their withdrawal. We shall have occasion
hereafter to notice other «defects of their qualities,” and
the way in which these subsequently stunted the further
development of their own movement. But it was largely
their very limitations which made them, at this particular
Crisis, such valuable representatives of the Trade Union
Movement. They accepted, with perfect good faith, the
eConomic Individualism of their middle-class opponents,
and claimed only that freedom to comkine which the
More enlightened members of that class were willing to
Concede to them. Their genuine if somewhat restrained
Sydney Waterlow, being at the bottom with 2,966 votes as against
4,382 ‘given for Odger. At the General Election of 1874 he again
Stood, to be once more opposed by both Liberals and Conservatives
With the same result as before, He died in 1877, his funeral, which
¥as attended by Professor E. Beesly, Professor Fawcett, and Sir Charles
Die, being made the occasion of a remarkable demonstration by the
London working men. An eulogy of him by Professor Beesly appeared
"the Weekly Dispatch, March 11, 1877.