Full text : The history of trade unionism

402

Alternation of Type.

Unionism ” of 1889, when the more progressive spirits
again plumed themselves on eliminating from their brandnew
 organisations the enervating influences of friendly
benefits.
A closer examination of the facts shows that this almost
rhythmical alternation of type has been only apparent.
The impartial student will notice that whilst the purely
‘rade society has been persistently adhered to by certain important
 industries, such as the Coalminers and the Cottonspinners,
 other trades, like the Engineers and the Ironfounders,
 have remained equally constant to the trade
friendly society ; whilst others, again, such as the Compositors
 and the Carpenters, have passed backwards and
forwards from one model to the other. But besides this
adaptation of type to the circumstances of particular
industries, we see also a preference for the purely trade
society on no higher ground than its cheapness. The
high contributions and levies paid by the Cotton-spinners
to their essentially trade society are as far beyond the
means of the Agricultural Labourer or the Docker as the
weekly premiums for superannuation, sick, and other
benefits charged to the Amalgamated Engineer. When,
as in 1833-4, 1872, and 1889, a wave of enthusiasm
sweeps the unskilled labourers into the Trade Union
ranks, it is obviously necessary to form, at any rate
in the first instance, organisations which make no greater
tax upon their miserable earnings than a penny or twopence
 per week. The apparent rhythm of alternations
between the two types of organisation is due, therefore,
not to any general abandonment of one for the other, but
to the accidental prominence, in certain crises of Trade
Union history, of the Unions belonging to particular
trades or classes of wage-earners. When, for instance,
the cotton-spinners, the builders, and the unskilled
labourers of 1834 loomed large to Francis Place as a
revolutionary force, the purely trade society appeared to
him to be the source of all that was evil in Trade
Unionism. When, in 1848-52, the iron trades were
            
Waiting...

Note to user

Dear user,

In response to current developments in the web technology used by the Goobi viewer, the software no longer supports your browser.

Please use one of the following browsers to display this page correctly.

Thank you.