xlvi
Introduction to the
slate-quarries, persists in the old attitude—at one time
almost universal—of refusing to enter into any collective
agreement as to the conditions under which the quarrymen
shall serve him. This dispute, which was temporarily
healed in 1896, broke out again in 1900, and after a
couple of years of heartbreaking struggle, ended in the
complete victory of the quarry-owner. Lord Penrhyn
takes his stand on the right of doing what he likes with
his own, even to the extent of closing the Bethesda slatequarries
against the world, if he cannot get workmen who
will let their wages be determined by Individual Bargaining.
The Board of Trade found itself powerless to bring to an
end. this little survival of ¢ private war,” which terminated
eventually in the exodus of many of the quarrymen and
the sullen submission of the remainder.
In the great dispute in the engineering trade in 1897-8,
though various other grievances were alleged on either
side, the issue of Collective Bargaining was directly raised.
The employers asserted, apparently with truth, that the
then existing conditions of employment militated against
efficiency ; that they found it difficult to introduce new
machines and new processes; and that the men were
reluctant to work them at their highest possible speed.
This difficulty had been experienced, at the corresponding
stage of industrial development, in various other trades,
notably that of cotton-spinning, in which it had been, for
more than a generation, most successfully surmounted.
But the engineering employers made no use of the dearly
bought experience of the master cotton-spinners, and
sought to attain their object in another way. Whilst disclaiming
any intention of reducing the general rate of
wages, they insisted on complete freedom for each em-