Medieval Building Trades.
9
and were unconcerned, therefore, with the making of
profit, whether upon the purchase and sale of materials or
upon the hiring of subordinate workers.! The stability
of their combinations was accordingly not prevented by
those influences which, as we have suggested, proved fatal
in England to the corresponding attempts of the hired
journeymen of the handicrafts,
But if the example of the building trades in the
Middle Ages supports our inference as to the cause
of the tardy growth of combination among the journeymen
in other trades, the « yearly congregations and confederacies”
of the masons might themselves demand our
attention as instances of early Trade Unionism. Of
the constitution, function, or ultimate development of
these medieval associations in the building trades we
know unfortunately nothing. It is remarkable that there
1s, sO far as we are aware, no trace of their existence
later than the fifteenth century. During the eighteenth
century there is, as we shall see, no lack of informa.
tion as to combinations of workmen in practically every
other skilled trade. The employers appear to have been
perpetually running to Parliament to complain of the
misdeeds of their workmen. But of combinations in the
building trades we have found practically no trace until
the very end of the century. If, therefore, adhering
strictly to the letter of our definition, we accepted the
masons’ confederacy as a Trade Union, we should be
compelled to regard the building trades as presenting the
unique instance of an industry which had a period of
Trade Unionism in the fifteenth century, then passed for
several centuries into a condition in which Trade
Unionism was impossible, and finally changed once
more to a state in which Trade Unions flourished.
* Dr. Brentano has noticed (p. 81) that the great majority of the
legal regulations of wages in the Middle Ages relate (if not to agricul
ture) to the building trades 5 and it may be that these were, like
modern cab-fare regulations, intended more for the protection of the
Customer than for that of the capitalist,