12 Craft Gild and Trade Union :
ward resemblance of the Trade Union to the Craft Gild
had long attracted the attention, both of the friends and
the enemies of Trade Unionism ; but it was the publication
in 1870 of Professor Brentano's brilliant study on the
“Origin of Trades Unions” that gave form to the
popular idea. Without in the least implying that any
connection could be traced between the medieval gild
and the modern Trade Union, Dr. Brentano suggested
that the one was in so far the successor of the other, that
both institutions had arisen « under the breaking up of an
old system, and among the men suffering from this disorganisation,
in order that they might maintain independence
and order.” 2 And when Mr. George Howell
prefixed to his history of Trade Unionism a paraphrase
of Dr. Brentano's account of the gilds, it became accepted
that the Trade Union had, in some undefined way, really
originated from the Craft Gild.3 We are therefore under
the obligation of digressing to examine the relation between
t Dr. Brentano's essay was originally prefixed to Toulmin Smith’
English Gilds, published by the Early English Text Society in 1870,
It was republished separately as Zhe History and Development of Gilds
and the Origin of Trades Unions (London, 135 pp., 1870), and it is to
this edition that we refer. Dr. Brentano's larger work, Die Aréeitergilden
der Gegenwart (Leipzig, 2 vols, 1871-2), includes this essay,
and also his article in the North British Review for October, 1870, on
“The Growth of a Trades Union.” It is only fair to say that in
this, the ablest study of English Trade Union history that has yet
appeared, Dr, Brentano lends no support to the popular idea of any
actual descent of the Trade Unions from the gilds. The Coéden Club
Essays (London, 1872) contain a good article on Trade Unions, by
Mr. Joseph Gostick, in which it is argued that these associations
were, in England, unknown before the eighteenth century, and had
no connection with the gilds. 2 Page 102.
3 The first hundred pages of Mr. George Howell's Conflicts of
Capital and Labour (London, first edition, 1877; second edition, 1891)
are a close paraphrase of Dr. Brentano’s essay, practically the whole
of which appears, often in the same words, as Mr, Howell's own,
But already in 1871 Dr. Brentano, in his Arbeitergilden der Gegenwart,
vol. i, ch. iii. p. 83, expressly connected the Trade Unions,
like Schanz, not with the gilds, but with the Journeymen Fraternities,
which he suggests may have “awaked under changed circumstances
to new strength and life, and to a new policy.”.