200 PONTIFICIAE ACADEMIAE SCIENTIARVM SCRIPTA VARIA - -
construction cost is only a partial offset; it is much easier
generally to make a plausible guess at an allowable construction
cost than to guess at an efficient output level. Another advant-
age is that there is some obscurity about the proper costs to
minimize in the cost minimization approach. The most plaus-
ible choice is total cost — the cost used in the denominator
of a conventional benefit-cost ratio — but this kind of cost
does not constitute a drain on any definable scarce resource,
it is an amalgam of construction costs in the near future and
operating costs extending through the life of the project. The
present value of the monetary net benefit stream has much
more appeal as the dimension of performance to be singled
out for special treatment.
The net benefit maximization approach also leads to shadow
prices, which may be even more usefully interpretable than
the shadow prices yielded by cost minimization. One of the
shadow prices will pertain to the construction cost constraint.
This price should surely be approximately the same for all
projects that are to be initiated in any brief time period, thus
facilitating inter-project comparisons and allocations.
My entire discussion has concentrated on the problem of
incommensurable benefits. There are also often incommensur-
able costs, and these can be handled in precisely the same way:
by establishing target levels and revising them in the light of
trial results. A few special cases of costs not measured ade-
quately in dollar terms deserve explicit mention. These are
all cases in which, perversely, a dollar is not worth a dollar.
Foreign exchange drain is an obvious instance: a country
may well be willing to forego more than a dollar in discounted
net benefits to save a dollar in foreign exchange. Inflationary
budgetary impact is another case. Most public investments
require heavy expenditures in some pattern extending over a
number of years. Anticipated budgetary tightness or inflation-
ary pressure may well be substantially different in some years
in the near future than in others. In such a case. total con-
3]
Dorfman - pag. 14