MAJORITY REPORT
403
but also of the Societies, which have a direct and legitimate
interest in the claims upon their funds for sickness and disable-
ment benefits. We cannot but feel that statistical inquiries of
the kind for which the present investigation has provided the
opportunity may be of the greatest value in aiding efficient
administration, and we would recommend the systematic institu-
tion of such inquiries, to be followed, systematically also, by
conference with the Societies upon such features of apparent
significance as the inquiries may reveal.
177. The importance of this subject is emphasised by con-
sideration of the Committee’s Report in another aspect. We
shall proceed immediately to discuss the margin in the contribu-
tions which the Committee find to be available for new purposes,
and we shall be compelled to indicate at various points in this
Report that we are restricted, in our recommendations as to
various extensions, by the comparatively small sum which
remains after provision has been made for certain additional
liabilities which must in any case be met. It was, perhaps, too
early in the history of the Scheme, especially having regard to
the abnormal conditions which have prevailed for a considerable
part of the time during which it has been in operation, to have
expected that the question of the margin in the contributions
could be permanently settled at the present time ; and from this
point of view we might reasonably look forward to the results of
another investigation after further experience, under more settled
conditions, has been gained. But it is evident that if the upward
tendency in certain of the claims for money benefit cannot be
brought under control, there is little prospect of more money
being released for new purposes at a later date. It is clear that
the best interests of the Scheme would be served if a basis for
hope, in this connexion, could be developed. Considering the
beneficial results on the health of the insured community which
ought to follow from the medical service provided by the Act,
and considering also the general advance in the education of the
people and the greater appreciation of hygienic conditions which,
as a result, is being disseminated, we feel that it is not unreason-
able to look for improved conditions so far as the claims are
concerned. But we realise that such an improvement may not
be fully secured without a general and definite endeavour to
keep the claims within their proper limits, regard being had, of
course, to the just and equitable treatment of the insured persons.
Systematic attention to the statistical results of the Approved
Societies’ work would assuredly promote the realisation of that
improvement and should accordingly be given a prominent place
among the matters of administration to which the attention of
the Departments and the Societies is continuously directed.
178. The effect of the Committee’s proposal, so far as relates
to the contribution payable to the Benefit Fund is to reduce the