ON SLAVE TRADE (EAST COAST OF AFRICA). 
xxi 
results in extinguishing the slave trade, without any addition to the Navy Estimates”— 
(Sir John Hay),—Question put, That those words be there inserted.—The Committee 
divided : 
Ayes, 3. 
Mr. Kinnaird. 
Sir John Hay. 
Mr. Robert Fowler. 
Noes, 6. 
Viscount Enfield. 
Lord F. Cavendish. 
Mr. O’Conor. 
Mr. Kennaway. 
Mr. Shaw Lefevre. 
Mr. Grilpin. 
Question, That the paragraph, as amended, stand part of the Report.—The Committee 
divided : 
Ayes, 6. 
Mr. Kinnaird. 
Sir John Hay. 
Mr. O’Conor. 
Mr. Kennaway. 
Mr. R. Fowler. 
Mr. Gilpin. 
Noes, 3. 
Viscount Enfield. 
Lord F. Cavendish. 
Mr. Shaw Lefevre. 
Paragrajih 42.—Amendment proj)osed in line 3, after the word “employed,” to insert 
the words : “ but they cannot help observing that the opinions of Admiral Hillyar and 
Sir Leopold Heath, the two officers who have commanded in these seas since 1867, 
have given evidence that an additional force must be maintained on this service; and it 
is further in evidence that at least three vessels are required to watch the Portuguese 
territory on the shores of the Mozambique”—(Sir John Hay).—Question put. That those 
words be there inserted.—The Committee divided : 
Ayes, 4. 
Mr. Kinnaird. 
Sir John Hay. 
Mr. Kennaway 
Mr. R. Fowler. 
Noes, 5. 
Viscount Enfield. 
Lord F. Cavendish. 
Mr. O’Conor. 
Mr. Shaw Lefevre. 
Mr. Gilpin. 
Another Amendment proposed, in line 3, to leave out the word “ and,” in order to 
insert the words : “ The Committee recognising how desirable it is that men and officers 
engaged on this monotonous and harassing service should not be detained for too long 
a period, recommend that more care should be taken in communicating to all naval com 
manding officers every information which may assist them in performing their duty, by 
providing them not only with accurate records of the proceedings of their naval prede • 
cessors, but with Parliamentary, Foreign Office, and India Office documents bearing on 
the question, which will assist them in forming a correct judgment as to the best mode of 
parrying the devices of the slave traders”—(Sir John Hay),—instead thereof.—Question 
put. That the word “and” stand part of the paragraph.—The Committee divided : 
Ayes, 5. 
Viscount Enfield. 
Lord F. Cavendish. 
Mr. O’Conor. 
Mr. Shaw Lefevre. 
Mr. Gilpin. 
Noes, 4. 
Mr. Kinnaird. 
Sir John Hay. 
Mr. Kennaway. 
Mr. R. Fowler. 
Paragraph agreed io. 
Paragraph 43, agreed to. 
Paragraphs 44—45, amended, and agreed to. 
Paragraph i6, agreed to. 
Paragraph 47.—Question put. That this paragraph stand part of the proj)Osed Report. 
I he Committee divided: 
Ayes, 7. 
Mr. Kinnaird. 
Sir John Hay. 
Lord F. Cavendish. 
Mr. O’Conor. 
Mr. Kennaway. 
Mr. R. Fowler. 
Mr. Gilpin. 
420. 
Noes, 2. 
Viscount Enfield. 
Mr. Shaw Lefevre. 
c 3 Amendment 
Q. C95, 696.11 
1157.1310.