64 
MINUTES OF EVIDENCE TAKEN BEFORE SELECT COMMITTEE 
Sir 
ly, Coghlan. 
<24 July 
1871. 
894. Supposing its reconsideration came before 
the Imperial or the Indian Government, do you 
think it should be decided on its own merits or 
mixed up with the slave question?—On its own 
merits, I think ; though I was reporting on the 
slave traffic, my principal business was the ad 
justment of affairs between the two Sultans. The 
slave traffic was merely a matter thrown .in. 
895. Mr. Kinnaird!\ It was not for want of 
representation, I think, from the Indian Govern 
ment that that opportunity was missed ; it was 
the Home Government who neglected the oppor 
tunity ?—I understand (in fact, some papers were 
sent to me on the subject) that the Governor 
General decided that it must be paid. 
896. His view being that it was a dynastic 
arrangement ?—Yes. 
897. When you returned to Aden, in 1863, 
three years subsequent to your report, did any 
additional evidence come before you at all to 
alter your report?—Nothing at all: in fact, the 
only way in which the question of the slave trade 
was mentioned to me on that occasion was by a 
complaint from some of the native merchants, 
who said that their traffic was interfered with by 
the cruisers ; they did not complain of the opera 
tion of the law ; they did not complain of vessels 
being interfered with which really carried slaves; 
but they said, in some cases, vessels which car 
ried no slaves were condemned, and with them 
all evidence of their character ; therefore, they 
said we are afraid to send our ships to sea. 
898. Do you believe, from your residence in 
the East, that a very large legitimate trade would 
grow up, if the slave trade was put down?—I 
have no doubt that there would be a large de 
velopment of trade on that coast. 
899. Have you any suggestions apart from 
your report to make, as to the best mode of sup 
pressing the slave trade ?—Obviously the first 
would be to get the Sultan of Zanzibar to cancel 
the treaty by which he is allowed to carry slaves 
within his own dominions. 
900. If he agreed only to have one port of export, 
which could be watched, would not that greatly 
facilitate the suppression of the trade ?—It would 
be still better to have none ; Sultan Majid, the 
one who died a few months ago, agreed with me 
that it should be so; he said, I will do anything 
you please, only I request you to remember that 
this forms a sixth part of my revenue. 
901. If our Government undertook to free him 
from that liability to pay 8,000 Z. a year, would 
he agree to the treaty being altered, and abolish 
the slave trade?—I should, think he would for 
less than that ; he said to me that this formed 
one-sixth part of his revenue; say that 19,000 
slaves were imported into Zanzibar ; upon that 
19,000 he got two dollars a head, that is 38,000 
dollars, that would be 7,000 Z. or 8,000 Z. 
902. Would that, in your opinion, be a very 
good mode of stopping the slave trade ?—I think 
so ; General Eigby is a better authority upon 
that subject than I am. 
903. Would not the relieving him from the 
payment of the amount of the subsidy be much 
cheaper than keejiing a large squadron on the 
coast ?—Yes. 
904. Mr. ./. Talhot.~\ Would it prevent the 
necessity of keeping a squadron on the coast?— 
Perhaps not altogether, because people would be 
found to break the law ; in fact, Europeans 
would do it. One of the greatest slave trafficker^ 
of my day was a Spaniard ; I saw his vessel cap' 
tured with^860 slaves on board. 
905. Mr. Crum-Ewing.~\ Where was he taking 
them to ?—I saw the vessel just after she wa= 
captured at the Mauritius. 
906. Were they taking them to Cuba?—Yes. 
907. Mr. Kitinaird.l What date was that?— 
About August or September I860; she was ^ 
large ship, captured by the Brisk.” 
908. Have you any reason to believe that ther® 
is even now a trade in slaves from the East Coasl 
of Africa to Cuba ?—I have no means of forming 
an opinion upon that. 
909. Sir J. Hay.~\ Is not the great difficult) 
in stopping the slave trade there more than 
any other place ; the difficulty in distinguishing 
between domestic slaves and slaves intended fot 
sale in foreign ports ?—That would be a difficult)' 
to naval officers, but during the time that I w»’ 
at Aden there was no difficulty of that sort! 
almost all the country craft that came into tb^ 
harbour were navigated by slaves ; we nevot 
thought of interfering with them ; but if a vessel 
had come in with slaves for sale, we should nt 
once have seized her, 
910. Mr. Crum~EwÙ7g.'\ You are of opinio^ 
that we cannot terminate the subsidy now paid to 
the Imaum of Muscat ?—I think not 
911. Is there no termination to it at all?-" 
When I made the award, I looked to a perio«^ 
when the two Governments would fall into onO 
hand as before, under the father; that was alwa)'^ 
looked to as a possible contingency. That, oí 
course, would have smoothed the difficulty oí 
once. 
912. Mr. jP. TVynd]iam.~\ Do you think thoi 
the Sultan of Zanzibar is likely now to be satis' 
tied with the same sum that you think wouD 
have satisfied him previously as a compensatio^ 
for giving up the slave trade ?—I think so. ^ 
found him tractable. 
913. You have no reason to believe that tb^ 
trade is more valuable to him now ?—No. 
914. Mr. Crum-Eicirg.~\ The Imaum of MuS' 
cat would look to the Sultan of Zanzibar in tb^ 
first instance for the payment of his subsidy?-^ 
Yes; there is no longer an Imaum of Muscat! 
he is the Sultan of Muscat ; of course he wouD 
look to his brother, but it is morally guarantee*^ j 
by the British Government. 
915. Mr. Kennaway.'] Did the Sultan of ZaH' 
zibar, in any conversation he had with you with 
reference to the slave trade, contemplate the po5' ' 
sibility of its being put down ?—Yes, I put tb^ : 
question to him, and you will find a reference 
it in my report. 
916. Did he see any difficulty in its being pn^ 
down ?—No ; he said I will do whatever yo^l 
please, only give me your support, by which 0* 
course I understood he meant money. 
917. Chairman.'] Not merely moral support- ' 
—No ; I quite understood he meant by that, that ' 
he wanted to be indemnified. 
918. Mr. Kennaioay.] Would he have be^^ 
satisfied with a few old arms ?—No, he had pleut) 
of them. 
919. Chairman.] Ig there anything you w'isb 
to add to the evidence you have given ?—I lua/ 
mention that, so far as the native chiefs withi*^ t 
the Gulf of Aden are concerned, I made a treat/ 
with, I think, every one of them ; I visited evef)