126
PONTIFICIAE ACADEMIAE SCIENTIARVM SCRIPTA VARIA - 28
safe to use endogenous variables as instruments is at least one
less for use in higher-numbered than for use in the same or
lower-numbered sectors.
As a matter of fact, our result is a bit stronger than this.
It is apparent from (5.26) that the use of endogenous variables
lagged 0% periods as instruments in higher-numbered sectors
involves covariances of the order of A+!H. Even the use of
endogenous variables lagged 6*+1 periods as instruments in
the same or lower-numbered sectors, however, involves cova-
riances of the order of only A® +1. No positive power of H is
involved in the first term of the expansion for the latter co-
variances. Since H is diagonal with diagonal elements less
than unity in absolute value, the difference between the mini-
mum lag with which it is safe to use endogenous variables as
instruments in the same or lower-numbered sectors and the
corresponding lag for use in higher-numbered ones may be
even greater than one. This point will be stronger the more
stable one believes the dynamic system to be. It arises because
the effects of serial correlation in sector and equation implicit
disturbances are direct in the case of lagged endogenous vari-
ables used in the same or lower-numbered sectors and are
passed through a damped dynamic system in the case of lagged
endogenous variables used in higher-numbered sectors (°°).
To sum up: so far as inconsistency is concerned, it is likely
to be safer to use endogenous variables with a given lag as
instruments in higher-numbered sectors than to use them in the
same or lower-numbered sectors. For the latter use, the endo-
genous variables should be lagged by at least one more period
to achieve the same level of consistency (31).
(°) All this is subject to the minor reservation discussed above concern-
ing sums each term of which approaches zero monotonically. In practice,
one tends to ignore such reservations in the absence of specific information
as to which way they point.
(*!) The reader should be aware of the parallel between this result and
the similar result for the use of current endogenous variables which emerges
when (BR.1)-(BR.3) are assumed. Essentially. we have replaced (BR.2)
with (5.10) and have dropped (BR.3).
61 Fisher - pag. 42